Feedback please on these mono images - Take 2

[Ozzie_Traveller]

G'day all

Thanks to Hans for his feedback for the first posting on this topic - and I agree that those images were less than ideal
The camera club comp is for "Mono Landscape" topics

Here's a different set of images for you to look at and =please= offer me some comments

1)-


2)-


3)-


Many thanks
Phil

[MJ224]

The last one has legs. You could make it a part colour and mono photo, maybe the tree in colour, of the misty island.

If I am honest, the first two are a bit dull. I thonk they would light up in colour though...

[Ozzie_Traveller]

Thx Mark - and 'yes' all 3 come up well as colour images, but this particular comp is for mono stuff ... tho back about a thousand yrs ago I was shooting heaps of mono and enjoying printing stuff for comps back then!
Phil

[Isac]

#2 for me Phil. Just needs a curves adjustment to give it more contrast, which is essential in BW photos as you know. #3 would be OK with some curves adjustments as well.

[Ozzie_Traveller]

Thanks fellas ... Good ideas too
Phil