BW conversion - need pointers

[Grumpy John]

I am trying to get a black & white version of this scene that "pops". I've tried Isac 's BW action, but can't get to pop, at least in my opinion.
Colour version


BW version

[Isac]

Is this what you mean by POP? There's a million ways to make things pop so it's up to the individual. BUT there are some tools and methods you can use for starters.
This one I thought needed to show more details in the darker areas so I used a couple of luminosity masks to achieve that. They are great for enhancing lights and shadows.

[Grumpy John]

That looks pretty good Isac, although there are a few "artifacts" around the tree and windmill. That may be because you weren't working the original file, just a small version.
The reduced shadow on the porch is perfect.

[Isac]

You're correct about the file size GJ. I use an action to create the luminosity masks if you want it.